In this video, you’ll see how to transform a basic Christmas cookie recipe into spooky, spindly witches’ fingers. You’ll also see simple tricks for making realistic-looking knuckles and fingernails. Dip these desiccated digits into seedless strawberry or raspberry jam for a little extra gore! They’re the perfect creepy cookie for Halloween parties. Watch the video, then get Sandra’s 5-star recipe for Spooky Witches' Fingers. So yummy it’s frightening.