Get Allrecipes Magazine!
Top-rated recipes and tips to inspire you year-round. Use coupon code DEAL to get a full year for just $5.
What makes it a yellow cake? It's the egg yolks. This tender butter cake is a birthday classic.
"THIS. WAS. PERFECTION. If anybody says it was dry they did not bake it right or mix it right." – kurlyy1
"Awesome! It's light, fluffy and has the perfect amount of sweetness. The batter is enough for an 8-inch 3-layer cake or 36 cupcakes." – lcat1031
"YES I'M SHOUTING FROM THE MOUNTAIN TOPS! THIS IS ABSOLUTELY THE BEST YELLOW CAKE EVERRRR." – Pamela Howie