I used Simply Jif for my peanut butter and prepared these cookies exactly as written except that I didn't have parchment paper so I had to grease the baking sheet. They came out super soft and they became a little more firm once they set after 5 minutes. As many others have said, you have to really love peanut butter to enjoy these cookies because that is what hits you when you eat them. I will make these again but I will use less sugar. They were too sweet for my liking but good flavour.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
I used Simply Jif for my peanut butter and prepared these cookies exactly as written except...