Because of my husband, I'm going with 5 stars. Me? I was disappointed. First, I only got 30 cookies from each batch so I obviously made them too large. The cookie was fine - great texture and nice, basic pumpkin cookie taste. But it was the reviews about the icing that drew me to this recipe and that's where I'm disappointed. I thought the icing tasted like nothing more than confectioners sugar and I did follow the recipe to the letter. If I make this in the future (for husband) I'll use just a tiny bit of icing on each cookie or go with a cream cheese frosting. Thanks for submitting! Can't please everyone, eh?
Was this review helpful?
2 users found this review helpful
Because of my husband, I'm going with 5 stars. Me? I was disappointed. First, I only got 30...