It's too bad the other reviewers didn't like these cookies because I thought they actually turned out great! I would give the recipe 5 stars if it were all about taste, but I have to say they were kind of a pain to make. The dough was VERY dry and crumbly, and there's no way you could "drop batter" by rounded teaspoons onto the cookie sheet -- i had to scoop up crumbs of dough and smoosh it into a ball, and then VERY CAREFULLY flatten them so the balls wouldn't just crumble. It's definitely more effort than I'd normally want to put into cookies, but I have to say that the end result was terrific: very pepperminty and not bland at all, and I am having a hard time not eating the whole batch in one sitting! Oh, and one other thing, it only made 3 dozen, not 4 dozen, but maybe I made mine bigger than I was supposed to.
Was this review helpful?
0 users found this review helpful
It's too bad the other reviewers didn't like these cookies because I thought they actually...