"The perfect 2-crust apple pie!" — Judy Pusko
Watch video tips and tricks
pastry for a 9 inch single crust pie
apple - peeled, cored and sliced
My husband Loves* apples pies. He absolutely loved the flavor of this pie. I am making it again today because he loved the taste. My problem with the pie is that it didn't hold it's shape very well when cut, and the crust was soggy on bottom. Was the pie filling too moist? I don't know, but will try agian today. Also, I followed the recipe and ended up with enough filling for two pies. (not a complaint*)
Based on all the great reviews I feel bad giving it 2 stars. But when I made it just as described, but the butter in the top "crust" laid on the top of the baked pie, like pizza grease! Gross. The bottom crust was soggy as well. I let it then sit in the oven longer to try to fix, no luck. Only thing I can guess is that my apples were very juicy?? Like the other reviewer, I had enough apple filling for two pies. Guess my 8 apples were twice as large as the cooks? But even so both pies turned out very very poorly. And it is the night before Thanksgiving! AAAA! Not good.
Pie was good. I put it in a brown paper bag in the oven rather than parchment paper.
It's a cool recipe
What a wonderful recipe! I was in such a hurry and this was so fast. My only change to the recipe was to double up on the cinnamon and nutmeg and I probably used more lemon juice too. I could tell right off that I was going to have way more filling than I need for a 9" dish, so I used two of my smaller dishes and it was perfect. I say "dishes" because the crust will be soggy if you use a pan, I am getting to be an old lady and experience tells me this. I have made a hobby of collecting pie dishes in all different sizes and depths so choosing the right one comes second nature now.
I used parchment which I always have on hand for cookies, fish and other dishes that I want to steam with other ingredients.
Someone mentioned using a paper bag, please don't use this unless your roasting a turkey, it gives off an odor and even a taste to baking that it doesn't to turkey. Everyone loved this and it was a bit different with the crumb crust, tasted very rich.
My thanks to Judy Pusko for offering this unique method....it was a first for me!
This is the apple pie my mother has made for me all my life. We always use a paper bag, it makes the house smell instantly of baking apples as soon as the oven door is closed. Love this recipe.
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Paper-Wrapped Apple Pie
Serving Size: 1/8 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 8
Amount Per Serving
Calories from Fat: 174
See how to make a simple, 5-star apple pie.
See how to make a simple apple pie with a flaky, golden-brown crust.
Learn how to make Chef John’s favorite apple pie recipe.