I did a half batch and added vanilla. While beating the sugar, butter, eggs and vanilla, I got distracted for about five minutes. When I returned to the kitchen, my batter was super fluffy. After mixing in dry ingredients, the batter was pretty wet, so I dropped in two handfuls of oatmeal. Then added 1/2 bag of mini Reese's Pieces. Made big balls by hand and fork pressed the tops like traditional PB cookies. Baked about 12 - 14 minutes. Now me, I hate PB cookies, but I did take a bite of one of these and they were moist and super peanut buttery. I wouldn't eat a whole one myself, but the PB fans in the house loved them a whole lot. Definitely better than a traditional PB cookie.
Was this review helpful?
0 users found this review helpful
I did a half batch and added vanilla. While beating the sugar, butter, eggs and vanilla, I got...