was not a hit, did not like it. sorry.

I made this with the "Absolutely Fabulous Greek Dressing." The basalmic vinegar gave the potatoes a very strange color, so I think I will not use it again. But it tasted REALLY good! My BIL didn't like it, but he's so picky that I didn't expect him to. Everyone else loved it. I also added kalamata olives for an extra mediterranean flare.

Like everyone at allrecipes does, I heavily modified this recipe for my tastes and pantry. I used green peppers versus bell peppers, & made dressing with dijon mustard, olive oil, and apple cider in equal parts. I added dill, taragon, and lemon pepper to taste. I omitted lemon juice and feta as I didn't have any and added marinated artichoke hearts. I love this recipe because it has a cold vinegar base instead of mayo. Thanks for the great idea!!!

Very bland to me

This is absolutely delicious! I tried this out at a graduation party for my son...I never test drive recipes at things like that. But, I have to say I did and it was a complete hit! Many asked for the recipe. Hockeymom you are a star! I used GOOD SEASONS ITALIAN DRESSING and toasted a whole small pkg. of pita bread (ripped up) and threw them in. It is very similar to a Lebanese Bread Salad. (Fattoush) We loved it thanks!

Giving this 4 stars for the modifications I made. Threw in sliced black olives, only about 2-3oz of feta, and just a few squeezes of lemon. I also didn't use Italian dressing, but whipped up a small batch of the Absolutely Fabulous Greek/House Dressing from this site and used that instead for a truly Greek treat! I let it sit overnight, then splashed in some more dressing right before I took this to a BBQ. Very awesome! I think it's the dressing that really makes this dish because the combination of ingredients really isn't anything special, so make sure you use a really good, robust dressing to set off the veggies and cheese.

This was great with just a few small changes to suit our tastes. I used really flavorful salad dressing which I think made the difference for us – Paul Newman’s Italian. I doubled the potatoes, dressing (not the lemon) and feta. Skipped the cucumber and did both red and orange peppers for color and crunch. This one tastes better at room temp - it was delicious tasting it when I first made it, and even better the next day! Thanks for a great recipe!

Ok, I'll admit it, I honeslty didn't measure anything, so I can't comment on the amounts as others did; I know that's not much of a help. Anyway, everyone enjoyed this different take on potato salad. Loved the feta addition. Thank you hockeymom!

I'd give this a 10 Plus. I could not stop eating it/half of it was gone before dinner! I followed the reviewers advice (so many agreed to the changes) - I only used a splash or two of lemon juice, I cut way back on the feta cheese and I used only 1/2 the amount of cucumber. The cucumber has a very strong taste in this salad. It was a hit - the next time though I am going to serve the Feta cheese on the side. Thank you so much submitter!

This was very good, but I made some significant changes. I cannot believe that you would really want to use this amount of feta; it must completely overwhelm the other ingredients. I used about 2 ounces of feta with the other proportions being the same. The other changes I made were as follows: used light italian dressing, added fresh parsley, and dried oregano.

Outstanding. Feta flavor was real strong. My kids liked it also, but it was because they love olives. I used kalamata and green olives. I didnt have a green pepper.

Wonderful! I like potato salad, but I usually find it has too much mayonaisse (or mustard eww!). This was amazing!

Tastes AND looks great. I made this with red and yellow peppers for color appeal added some Kalamata olives to the mix. Like previous reviewers I only added lemon juice to taste and the result was a unique potato salad perfect for summer. My husband hates typical mayo intense potato salad so he was hesitant when I said I was making potato salad but this was big hit!

This recipe provides a great foundation for many alterations...I, like some of the previous reviewers, used a little less of the fresh lemon. also i bumped up the "mediterrainean" feel of this by adding a fistfull of mixed green and black olives that had been thinly sliced. Also a sprinkle of mixed herbs and small drizzle of olive oil, to compensate for the reduced use of lemon juice! great on its own and also with the pittas....if you do serve with pittas....serve them warm with a dollop of hoummous smeared on the inside!