Recipe by youngwoman
"My version of Ruby Tuesday's New Orleans Seafood, minus the shrimp. I merged a few different recipes and came up with this. It comes pretty close! Three fillets are usually enough for my husband, my toddler, and myself. I serve this with rice and steamed broccoli, to really feel like Ruby Tuesday's recipe!"
Watch video tips and tricks
Creole seasoning, or to taste
This is a simple yet delicious way to serve Tilapia! I had my dinner ready in about 15 minutes...which is amazing for me! I season my fillets with either Penzey's Northwoods Seasoning or Penzey's Jerk seasoning and while it's baking, I make up a quick home-made Alfredo Sauce with 1/4 cup of butter, some fresh garlic, 1/2 cup of half & half, 3/4 cup good Parmesan (grated) and a little Italian seasoning. (Just saute the garlic in the butter over med/high heat, then add the other ingredients, stirring until blended.) This recipe is definitely a keeper - thanks for a new way to serve up Tilapia!
I liked the fact that the recipe is easy with ingredients found readily at home. I thought it tasted good, but not great.
This recipe is FANTASTIC. I'm sure it's wonderful with the Creole seasoning but I can't eat spicy food so I used Johnny's Seasoning instead. When the sauteed garlic was just right I added some raw shrimp and cooked them until they were almost done, added the Alfredo sauce and heated it throughly. By the time the sauce was ready to top the fish the shrimp were perfectly cooked. Who needs to go out to eat. This is fare fit for a king.
Out of the 10 recipes I have tried on this site this is my favorite. I used the roasted red pepper alfredo instead of regular alfredo and it was amazing.
OMG...this just works!!! I was a bit hesitant to top my beloved tilapia with alfredo sauce. I am so glad I did as it takes it from wonderful to amazing! I bake my tilapia the same way, but have never added a topping. I did take Westie Mom's advice and made my own alfredo sauce as I don't care for the jarred stuff. I followed her recipe for the sauce which is: 1/4 C butter, fresh minced garlic, 3/4 C parmesan cheese, 1/2 cup half and half and a bit of Italian seasoning. It was perfect! I actually used 2 T fat free half and half and 2 T heavy cream because this is what I had. Do yourself a favor and make this sauce! You only need a couple tablespoons for each piece of fish so it is worth the splurge! Thanks for a great recipe!
i used to work at ruby tuesday so i have had the new orleans seafood many many times! and have served it 100s of times. and this looked and tasted so much like it. it was delicious!! and really easy to make. i followed the recipe exactly. and used classico low calorie alfredo sauce! yum yum yum
Very Very Tasty! I did make my own alfredo sauce for this because jared ones are just not very good. This was gobbled up by all three of my children. It has been put on the "make again" list!
I was a little worried about the alfredo with fish, but it was de-lish! Wish I had some broccoli or asparagas to go with it though, I think that would have really complimented the dish!! Thanks for a great meal!
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Garlic Alfredo Tilapia
Serving Size: 1/4 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 4
Amount Per Serving
Calories from Fat: 315
Everything you need to party like a leprechaun.
New for spring! Good-for-you food you’ll love to eat.
Delicious recipes, party ideas, and helpful cooking tips! Get a year of Allrecipes magazine for just $9.99!
Make this popular restaurant dish from scratch--it's easy and so tasty.
See how to make a mild baked fish that’s quick, healthy, and flavorful.
Prepare a healthy and delicious meal in just a handful of minutes.