Pretty good! While I prefer Graden's classic macaroni salad a *touch* better, this was also quite good. This is a very heavy, mayonnaise-laden salad (if you're not a fan, continue your search for a recipe that better suits your tastes). Graden'saversion is lightly dressed and has a less creamy texture (her dressing is a bit runny in comparison). Both salads have a sweet aftertaste that makes them VERY similar. NOTE: As many others have done, I too dressed my salad with HALF of my dressing and saved the rest to add as I saw fit. I also reduced the sugar to 1/2 c. and was pleased with the result (3/4 c. sugar would be overkill, IMHO). All in all, I found this to be yummy and a great contribution to the fish fry dinner my hubs and I were invited to. Actually, I have been requested to make this (again) for our upcoming block party next month! Thanks for sharing, Connie! :-)
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
Pretty good! While I prefer Graden's classic macaroni salad a *touch* better, this was also...