Why are my cookies bitter?
I made the delicious-looking cookies from this website: http://www.ldsliving.com/story/64185-food-dish-cookie-recipe-contest-winner-recipe .
Before cooking, they tasted absolutely delicious, like lemon cream cheese frosting. (I only tried a little taste). After cooking, the flavor was still a perfect balance of tangy and sweet, but the after taste was just bitter, with no lemon flavor at all -- and lasted much longer than the cookie. Also, the sugar crystalized and stuck to my teeth as I chewed on the cookies, so I really think there is too much sugar in this recipe. Finally, they did not spread out, as I expected from the picture. Rather, they swelled up, and then some fell back down and looked sort-of like the picture. The others did not fall, and were hollow in the middle. While it could be the lemon that caused the bitterness, I don't think so because I think that would be more sour than bitter, and I carefully avoided the white part of the lemon. Could it be having so very much sugar that did it? Or was it something to do with the lemon after all, like a chemical they may have sprayed on the peel? Since the sweet/lemon ratio already tastes perfect, would it come out too sour if I just reduce the sugar? Should I perhaps add more flour instead? What do you suggest?
Jan. 28, 2013 3:24 pm
We do our best to make sure that Allrecipes user contributions are appropriate, but if you see anything questionable, please let us know
so we can address the issue.