I would've given this 5 stars for the delicious, most yummy peanuty buttery burst of flavor. No pb cookie has a better, more robust flavor. Unfortunately, these cookies (most of them) were so very soft I could bend them in half & make a sandwich. Plus most very flat. Now I have been baking for years & consider myself an excellent baker. I so much wanted to love these cookies after reading the reviews, and I do love the flavor, but not the texture. The texture ruins it for me--to the point of not wanting to make them again. First I made very small ones(walnut size? Really?? ) and baked 10 min. That batch was rather dry & the bottom was starting to turn dark brown. I normally make all my cookies rather large, so next batch tried making larger at 10min. Those turned flat like pancakes and very soft(bendable). Medium size, hardly pressed with the fork tines at 10 min. looked about the best.
Was this review helpful?
9 users found this review helpful
I would've given this 5 stars for the delicious, most yummy peanuty buttery burst of flavor. ...