I have made a LOT of dessert recipes on this site & this cookie, by far is the winner, so far. My picky 24 yr old son loves them. I sent my daughter's fiance home with 4 of them just to try out & he ate 2 on the way home, TRIED to hide them from my daughter, let her have one (in his defense she's dieting) & then begged for more. I sent over 6 more & today he asked for more. My husband says their so good I could sell them. wow. I never expected all that. The only subs I made were 2: I used crunchy pb for the cookie part & I didn't have any heavy whipping cream so I used half-n-half. They are extremely sweet but that doesn't seem to stop anyone from eating them! I frankly don't think they taste anything like the Girl Scout version. Their cookie is crunchy & the filling is firmer. I like this version better; the cookie stays soft & the filling is a little creamier. I store mine in a Tupperware container in the fridge. It's just a personal preference; we all seem to like them better that way. I made mine with a small scoop (one bigger than a melon baller) & I like that size. They sort of remind me of the Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pies as far as size & texture of cookie & filling - again but way better! Some one has asked me to try making them & then dipping them in a chocolate coating. I may just try that on a few & see if my victims don't die of a sugar overdose! I will be making these again this weekend, by popular demand. Thanks Joanne!
Was this review helpful?
7 users found this review helpful
I have made a LOT of dessert recipes on this site & this cookie, by far is the winner, so far....