Based on the name of these cookies I was expecting a lot more from them. They aren't terrible, but they are definitely not the best I've had. I followed the recipe almost exactly as written, except I used 2 x-large eggs because that's all I had and I omitted the nuts. Baking them at 350 was taking well beyond 10 minutes, so I knew the oven temp had to be increased. Also, the cookies were not browning and looked flat. After the first batch came out I increased the oven temp to 375 and baked for 11 minutes. The cookies seemed to have a better color to them and didn't seem as flat. As far as taste goes these cookies are decent, but I must say I've yet to find a chocolate chip cookie recipe that I like as much as Tollhouse. For me, that is definitely the recipe to beat. Will I make these cookies again? Probably not.
Was this review helpful?
5 users found this review helpful
Based on the name of these cookies I was expecting a lot more from them. They aren't terrible,...