This is the first time I've made pumpkin bread. After reading both the good and the bad reviews I decided to go with the substitution version, and do one loaf and one batch of muffins. Except, I broke the cardinal rule of baking and didn't check to make sure I had all the ingredients first. I ended up having to make some applesauce out of peaches (peachlesauce?), and then make some clarified butter because I had no vegetable oil. The two combined still produced a springy, moist result. I also added chocolate chips to both and chopped almonds to the tops of the muffins, added vanilla, some orange zest, and I cut back on the sugar. 3 cups seemed WAY too much in my opinion. I only used 2 cups of white sugar and about a quarter of a cup of molasses. It makes them more balanced and lets the spice flavor come through. However, I do have to agree with some of the one-star reviews. There is very little actual pumpkin flavor, which is strange considering that the spice proportions are similar to a pumpkin pie. It's still delicious, but I think it could be renamed as a spice bread and be more accurate.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
This is the first time I've made pumpkin bread. After reading both the good and the bad...