Wow, what a great recipe. And what could be better than delicious, easy and inexpensive? Yes, you do have to take leap of faith with this one, and I'm so glad I did. Since I'm a fan of "two-fer" dinners, I started with a 4 lb eye of round to insure leftovers and made my own rub of olive oil, a bit of gravy browning sauce and a TINY smidge of liquid smoke, sea salt, pepper, garlic and onion powders and paprika. I used my hands and rubbed the mixture in well over the entire roast, then placed it on a Pam-sprayed rack in a baking dish. I cranked up the oven to 500 and left it on a bit per other reviewer suggestions, turned it down to 475, then followed the 7 min/lb rule and turned the oven off. I planned to take it out 3 hours later, but had about a delay, so roast ended up spending about 4 hours after the initial cook time. My oven holds heat well, so roast was still warm. Outside looked dry and the ends, of course were well done (but tasty) when I sliced off a bit to sample. But cutting into it revealed a beautiful pink, juicy center and oh, so delicious. My 10-year had 4 servings and even my picky 12-year old son had seconds. In my opinion, would have been even better if I'd taken it out at the 3-hour mark (I like mine more on the rare side). I served with Horseradish Sauce on this site and the meat just melted in your mouth -- yes, do slice very thinly. The leftovers will make perfect French Dip sandwiches for dinner later this week. BEST roast I've ever made!!!
Was this review helpful?
14 users found this review helpful
Wow, what a great recipe. And what could be better than delicious, easy and inexpensive? Yes,...