Came out fabulous!

Reviewed On: Mar. 31, 2013

Fabulous cookie! One afternoon while feeling pretty adventurous, I thought I would compare this cookie recipe to another cookie recipe (called Felix K's Don't even try to say these aren't the best you've ever eaten, because they are Chocolate Chip Cookies, also on this site). I am an experienced baker and followed the directions of both recipes as they were written (didn't change them based on any comments, so that I could compare one original recipe to the other). I was looking for a cookie where the base of the cookie is buttery with a hint of salt, balanced by some delicious chocolate chips. I also wanted a tender cookie. I found that this recipe (Best choocolate Chip Cookies submitted by Dora) fit that bill to a "t"! So, from now on, I am going to make that one. I found that these Felix K cookies were dry and floury. They definitely resemble what you get at a bakery. Some people like that kind of cookie, and if you do like that big floury flat cookie, then that is the recipe for you. My sister like Felix K's recipe better, so it all depends on what you are looking for. For me, this recipe here is a keeper! Happy baking!

Reviewed On: Dec. 17, 2012

One afternoon while feeling pretty adventurous, I thought I would compare this cookie recipe to another cookie recipe (called Best Chocolate Chip Cookies, submitted by Dora, also on this site). I am an experienced baker and followed the directions as they were written (didn't change them based on any comments, so that I could compare one original recipe to the other). I found that these Felix K cookies were dry and floury. They definitely resemble what you get at a bakery. Some people like that kind of cookie, and if you do like that big floury flat cookie, then this is the recipe for you. I was looking for a cookie where the base of the cookie is buttery with a hint of salt, balanced by some delicious chocolate chips. I also wanted a more tender cookie. I found that the other recipe that I mentioned above (Best Chocolate Chip Cookies submitted by Dora) fit that bill to a "t"! So, from now on, I am going to make that one. My sister however, liked Felix K's better, so, like I said, it depends what you are looking for. Happy baking!

Reviewed On: Dec. 17, 2012