Made this for my husband's birthday and we both LOVED it! I didn't have a zester, so I tried using a potato peeler and a paring knife to get the zest, but it was not working well. So, there was not even an 1/8 of a teaspoon of zest, and the pie still turned out delicious. This pie is heavy, sweet and slightly tart ... the way we like it. For some reason, I had to use close to 40 key limes to get the right amount of juice. And, I made this with the homemade Whipped Cream by Paula. P.S. Buy three cans of condensed milk as others say. Two cans do not equal three cups, and three cups do not overflow the store-bought Keebler graham cracker crust.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
Made this for my husband's birthday and we both LOVED it! I didn't have a zester, so I tried...