I'm sorry, but we really did not enjoy this recipe. The cookies are soft, but it's in a gritty, fluffy way that wasn't pleasing in our opinion. Admittedly, we didn't use vanilla pudding mix, but chocolate, which may have detracted from the flavor. While mixing the flour into the creamed butter and sugar, the mix was so dry that I had difficulty even getting it mixed, so it may well have been overworked. I would consider myself a pretty proficient cookie baker, and I like to bake all different kinds of cookies. I think I must have done something wrong with these, since so many other reviewers enjoyed them. After baking the first round, we were so disappointed with the finished product that we didn't even bother to bake the rest of the dough. For us, they were the worst cookies I've ever made.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
I'm sorry, but we really did not enjoy this recipe. The cookies are soft, but it's in a...