I should have given it 5 stars but since only my husband tried it, I'm giving it four. This was the first pumpkin pie I had ever made and the night before making this, my aunt, who is the equivalent of Martha Stewart, told me I had ruined my pie by adding Sweetened condensed milk. Said it should have been Evaporated milk. By then, I had thrown out the piece of paper I had this recipe on and looked thru cookbooks to find she was correct that most pumpkin pies do have Evap. milk. So I did not serve this pie to anyone even though it was beautiful!!!! My husband then tried the pie a couple days later and said it was "Wonderful!!!" better than the one I actually served! Easy for my first pie too!!
Was this review helpful?
2 users found this review helpful
I should have given it 5 stars but since only my husband tried it, I'm giving it four. This...