I honestly don't think you can make a bad potato anything using Yukon Golds. The color alone is beautiful and they're almost rich tasting all by themselves. This recipe was wonderful Robyn and I thank you.

Really yummy! Instead of the evaporated skim milk, I added half & half to enhance the creaminess. My two year old, who won't touch regular mashed potatoes, asked for these leftovers for days! It was a hit when I served them for Thanksgiving dinner!

Great with a beef dish. Would make again.

A lot to go through for onion flavored mashed potatoes.

Mixer is actually optional, if you'd like to make it easier! Just grated yukons on the second largest side of my old fashioned 4 sided grater, once dried. Tukons are so fluffy by the time you add the shallot mixture they seem mashed already & don't get "gummy" from the mixer. I cut up the skins that didn't grate & kept in for fiber(although I couldn't really see where the recipe has you take them off). I will try the shallots via saute until carmelized, as thinking you could cook potatoes the night before, leave in fridge in their jackets, grate them then nuke & add shallot mixture. (Have nuked cooked Yukons easily in past.) In this way it wouldn't take so long to get dinner on the table after a long day at work. I served with tilapia as DH needs potatoes with fish or chiken to call be satisfied. Does anyone know if fiber is as low as shown? Seems should be higher if skins left on? Truly a fabulous five & deserves more any time you can get potatoes in them without butter! Thank you ever so much!

Thank you Robyn, this turned out perfect, we served with creamy herbed pork chops from this site, and it was a real winner. No changes or tweaks needed!

This is definitely a keeper recipe. I made this tonight and served it with a cajun seasoned grilled steak. Yummy! I used about 1 1/2 pounds of small Yukon Gold potatoes. My husband thought the shallots were strong, so next time I'll cut back on them by a couple of tablespoons. Though I probably exceeded the initial 6 tablespoons. I thought it was great.

These were great. I paired them with the Stuffed Pork Crown Roast, french green beans and potato crescent rolls all found on this site and it was a dinner to remember. Excellent!

Absolutely delicious! The shallots and fresh thyme give the potatoes a wonderful aroma and flavor. Mincing the shallots is time consuming, but well worth it. My roomates loved it!

This mouth-watering dish was such a hit, I was forced at fork-point to make it three nights in a row. I had to promise to make it again the following week before I was permitted to skip a few nights. The potatoes were so rich, yet fluffy and light and they did an excellent disappearing act. Thanks for this one. It's a real winner!

This was one of the finest mashed potato receiptes we have ever used. The Yukon gold's taste terrific. We served this on a X-mas day sit down dinner for 8 and most of our guests ate the potato's dry because they tasted so good.

I was very disappointed with this recipe. The flavor was very bland and not at all what I expected. I spent more time trying to doctor this recipe up than I did preparing it. I will not be making this again.