Best barbeque ever, in my book! The only thing I changed was using steak sauce instead of Worchestershire, just because it's what I had. I let it cook all day on low in the crock, then put it on the stovetop for about 45 min on medium-low to thicken the sauce. "Dipping" the buns is a great tip, too. Would make a great 'stuffed' baked potato, IF there were any leftovers! Sending this recipe to my whole family, thanks so much for sharing!!

This makes a lot of beef barbeque. Mom never made it, but up North we used to have it every now and then for school lunch. I live in the South now, where pork barbeque is king and chicken barbeque comes in second and beef barbeque is rare. But I had a chuck roast I wanted to do something different with so I thought I’d cook some up. Southern hubby gobbled it up. It was great as sandwiches on hamburger rolls. I made this just as written (including open crock sauce thickening and dipping the bun tops) except left out the celery since I had none. I did add 1 tsp. celery seed for a touch of the celery flavor though. I used a good Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce. I only had a 3 ½ lb. roast, but even so, the recipe makes a lot of sauce even if it had been the 4 lb. one specified. Tasty and hearty beef barbeque, all around. Not too sweet, not too spicy. I thought, just about right for the beef. I might tweak it with a little liquid smoke next time. Not hard to make at all. Don’t let the long list of ingredients intimidate you. All are pretty common things you probably have on hand. It really only took me a few minutes to measure out all the stuff in the sauce and you only have to chunk / chop up one onion. I served this with my favorite “Taste of Home’s Creamy Coleslaw” (from this site) that I whipped up in no time. This is a good meal for a day when the family is on the run. Leave the slow cooker on warm, set the package of hamburger buns out on the counter, and let everyone serve them

I really didn't care much for the sauce when I first tasted it. I added more chili powder, garlic, and brown sugar to the crock pot. It was better after that, but still didn't wow me. I used boneless beef chuck ribs and just let them slow cook on low with the sauce overnight. Won't make this sauce again, but the meat was really easy to shred.

Fantastic! I discovered too late that I was out of ketchup, so I just used the better part of a bottle of Sweet Baby Ray's barbeque sauce. Roast got amazingly tender in the crock pot, and made terrific sandwiches - plus plenty of leftover beef that we froze for another meal. We'll definitely be making this again - maybe with pork roast next time. Thanks!

AWESOME!!!

This is great! I rubbed it with cajun seasoning and browned it to spice it up first. I also added a teaspoon of colemans dry mustard and few pepper flakes to the sauce. I also used KC masterpiece and did not need any extra on my sandwich. I never need to try another bbq beef recipe.

This recipe was excellent. If you follow it exactly it thickens up perfectly. The only changes I made was : I rubbed my roast with cajun seasoning and seared it in vegetable oil before putting it in the slow cooker, and I added 1/2 teaspoon of crushed red pepper flakes to the sauce. I used Sweet Baby Ray's for my bbq sauce. These sandwiches had just the right kick and were the best I've had .I will be using this recipe again . Thanks!

I have not tried this recipe yet, but logged on to find a beef barbeque recipe and lo and behold Ting Town popped up. I couldn't believe my eyes. I grew up in Hibbing Ting-Town was always the first stop on the way to Bimbos and McCarthy's Beach! I can't wait to try this recipe! Its gotta be the best!

I have never responded to any review, but had to on this one. This is absolutely delicious. Will never need to look further for a BBQ recipe!!! Terrific

Pretty good....not spicy or tangy enough though. I think it needed more of a bbq taste to it..?