This is really good! I read the other reviews and did some addlibing. I added a few dashes of Worchestershire sauce, about 3 table spoons of Texas Pete, a couple shakes of Cajun seansoning, a dash of A1 and since I didn't have any honey, I used Caro syrup. Oh, and I did add extra onion and doubled the garlic like the others did. It was great! It had a more BBQ flavor, and had a little kick to it, but not too much! Served it over rice. I will certainly be making this again!

very good following the yips provided.

This was a very tender beef and it did taste very good, but it did not taste like BBQ at all. It was more like a roast. I would make it again, but not when we are in the mood for BBQ.

This is a wonderful recipe. Start it the night before and there is nothing left to do until next day. Very tender and it pulls apart with fork. Even fussiest eaters enjoy it. Made it with worchestire sauce as well. Both ways fantastic

We had tried other barbecue's and there was always something missing. This one had the right flavors we were looking for.

This turned out yummy. It wasn't as flavorful as I had hoped, so I added some extra zing...garlic, a little Lawry's seasoning salt, which livened it up. Just the right amount of moisture, though, the texture of the roast was perfect. Will definitely make again

This was great. My son and his friends loved it. Will cook again.

This was good but didn't have a very BBQ flavour. The sauce was more a spicy tomato flavour than BBQ. I still prefer BARBECUED BEEF from this site.

I was planning to make a different roast but didn't have all the ingredients. Fortunately, I stumbled across this delight. I made this exactly as written, with the exception of the cooking time. I cooked it on high for six hours. I will definitely make this recipe again, except next time I will add a few drops of Tabasco or perhaps a jalapeno-based sauce to wake the sauce up a bit. Don't get me wrong, there is nothing wrong with the sauce as is, and my husband liked it as is, but a smidgeon of some spice would make it pop just a little.

Based on previous reviews, I ad-libbed a bit. I put in 2/3 cup of onions, twice the minced garlic, added several dashes of worchestershire sauce and two tablespoons of honey. The sauce was wonderful & I served it over white rice. Great recipe!

We love this recipe. This is quick, easy and very filling.

I added some bbq sauce instead of tomotoe sauce added a few drops of hotsauce it turned out well

Awsome! Quick to make. Leftovers were great the next day.

Great sauce. We loved this.

I didn't find it to be very flavorful. In fact, we added bbq sauce to the sandwiches while eating in order to have some pep.

Didn't like the sauce so much, however, we used the high temperature method...might be better to cook longer at the low temperature.

I WAS NOT THRILLED WITH THIS RECIPE AT ALL..I THINK IT IS TASTIER AND EASIER TO GET A GOOD NAME BRAND BBQ SAUCE AND USE THAT INSTEAD...ALTHOUGH IT WAS EDIBLE I WILL NOT MAKE THIS AGAIN.