I rated it 5 stars, not based on my love for the recipe, but because the recipe is what it is...a Shaker Lemon Pie! It may not be my favorite lemon pie, but there is nothing wrong with the recipe, it is supposed to taste like this. I changed it a tad, I used 3 lemons and added 1/3 cup of sugar and used 5 eggs. I wanted a thick pie, I don't like thin fillings. After 24 hrs (no way would I bake this pie after it sitting only 4 hrs) I ran it through the blender to reduce the size of the pieces.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
I rated it 5 stars, not based on my love for the recipe, but because the recipe is what it...