delicious! mine didn't really thicken either, but it was still a good consistency. i used so soya slices and chick peas b/c i couldn't track down seitan, alas.

Excellent! Tastes like authentic Indian food!! Will be making it again! Added Spinach and Broccoli, didn't have garam masala so we made this we found online that did the trick, doubled for the ~4 tablespoons needed by this recipe: 1/2 tsp cumin 1/2 tsp paprika 1/4 tsp cinnamon 1/4 tsp cayenne pepper 1/4 tsp crumbled bay leaves 1/8 tsp ground cloves The only complaint is that it didn't get thick like the picture (or at all), but it came out just fine.

Awesome! I doubled my spicing and added a pinch hing (traditional Indian spice). I also used a can of diced tomatoes, as I didn't have any tomato paste on hand. Still turned out great!

I made the sauce part as written with the addition of a cut up tomato. The spices were subtle but good. I found that it needed a touch of sweetness so I added about two teaspoons of agave syrup. That was just right. I made my own seitan from scratch. Because my seitan was firmer than store bought, I didn't bother with frying it. I just added it to the sauce and let it heat through. I thought the sauce was just the right consistency as is so I didn't add the cornstarch. This was not the best makhani I've ever had but it was pretty good and I'm sure I'll be making it again, with a few minor tweaks.

This is a nice indian recipe. Tried it with Tofu and that worked out good. I doubled the spices (as people recommended it) because i like spicy food, but that made it way to spicy. It also made it quite chunky and thick. Will try again with normal amount of spices.