"Paneer is an essential ingrediant in Indian cooking. Often people substitue riccotta or some other kind of cheese. But they never taste the same and paneer is so easy to make. With this simple recipe, you'll give true Indian authenticity to all your dishes." — DOSTANDEN
Watch video tips and tricks
fresh lemon juice
Being an indian, we use regular milk in making paneer. I am assuming that Dostanden ment to put that in the recipe. Usually the higher the fat content in milk, the better and more paneer you will get.
I have no idea what I am doing wrong, but I tried this recipe twice and I didn't get any cheese. It wouldn't curdle at all. I used whole milk.
Paneer is quite easy to make. Definitely requires whole milk. One thing this recipe doesn't mention is that the milk has to curdle. This occurs once you put in the lemon juice. I have seen it not curdle, perhaps due to less acidic lemons. Lemon can be substituted with white vinegar, especially if your lemons won't cause it to curdle. Toss some fresh cracked peppercorns into the curdled milk in the cheese cloth and stir before hanging for peppercorn paneer.
Okay, here's how it worked for me. I made the recipe as it is written using whole milk and got some curds (about 3/4 cup) with remaining liquid that looked like 2% milk, not whey. It seemed like I could get more out of it, so I cooled the mixture down to room temperature, then heated it to boiling again and added a tablespoon of white vinegar as suggested by another reviewer. It curdled beautifully leaving a clear whey and more solids than the first attempt. My advice is to go straight for the vinegar as the acidity of lemons may vary from one to the next. The paneer tastes excellent with a nice firmness that held its shape when cut.
the taste was fantastic, but i did not know how much the recipe was supposed to make - i used fat free milk and did not get much out of it (8 servings = apx 6oz of cheese) but i suspect if i use full fat milk, it is going to get a lot more cheese...but the taste is WONDERFUL
This is a great recipe, and so easy to make. Those of you who couldn't get your milk to curdle, it's possible that you didn't get your milk hot enough. I only got a tiny bit of cheese the first time through, then I put the milk back in the pan and reheated it. I didn't add anything extra, I just stirred until I saw the first bubble of a boil. I poured it through the sieve again, and it worked beautifully!
Finally! A paneer recipe that worked! I made this yesterday and am using it tonight in Rosy's Palak Paneer.
I did read the posts about full-fat milk working better. Since all I had was 2 percent, I substituted a half pint light cream for 1 cup of the milk. Also, the yogurt I used was Stoneyfield Organic full fat with cream on top. So I added a little of the cream from on top of the yogurt ;-) This did require more than one Tb of lemon juice in order to curdle, but it all comes down to how acidic the lemon is, I guess.
The cheese is DELICIOUS (been nibbling at the curds that stuck to the cheesecloth... LOL) and firm enough to cook. Thank you SO MUCH for posting this recipe!
Crumbly the first time - allow curdling to take place while heating on medium - might have to add extra lemon juice
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Paneer (Home Made)
Serving Size: 1/4 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 4
Amount Per Serving
Calories from Fat: 44
Holiday cookies, cakes, pies, and breads. Get recipes and inspiration.
Get time-saving recipes to save your busy life.
Find just the right recipes for your holiday get-togethers.
This homemade Indian chicken curry dish is so delicious, you won’t miss takeout.
See how to make your own Indian spice blend at home.
See how to make traditional Japanese teriyaki sauce from scratch.