This had a very nice taste and texture with almost a custard-like layer between the apples. I melted the butter for the batter but used softened butter to cut in for the topping. It took alot longer than the instructed time to cook at 325°. Makes for a great breakfast treat when re-heated.

I took some liberties with this: added maybe 1c. cranberries, the apples were already seasoned from another apple pie and I used a stoneware pie plate. It took nearly 2 hours at 350. Finally I shut the oven off with the pie inside and went to do my hair - came back and it was finally done. Hopefully it eats as good as it looks - which is pretty awesome.

Best Apple pie I ever made! I'm not fond of regular crust so this pie is great. It is moist and yummy. I did add a bit more spice to my taste. I had to make 4 pies because everyone wanted one! Totally Yummy, thanks for the recipe! clare~~~

I modified this recipe a little bit by substituting rhubarb for the apples. It is more like a cobbler but very tasty with a crisp crust on the top. Delicious. We enjoyed it very much.

I made this with a combination of Gala and Granny Smith apples, and also walnuts and pecans. I think I prefer a traditional pie crust, but this was definitely nice for a change. Thanks, Brenda!

Hubby says, "This is not a traditional apple pie, but for the ease of how it's made and a traditional apple pie taste, this is a winner." But I say the crust was kind of soggy, and I prefer the flakiness of a traditinal pie crust, even if you're buying one already prepared to save time. Hubby wants me to make this one a keeper, I say let's try something else. But hey, it does use some of that huge Costco box of Bisquick in my pantry!

My mother used to make tis pie when I was a Kid. I have been making it since I got married 57 years ago it is still a favorite in my hosehold. Put a big dollop of whipped cream on the top and yummie yummie

Very good. Thank you for the wonderful recipe.

Delicious! This is the first pie I've ever made and it turned out perfectly. I shared with some friends who called it "decadent."

This is yummy! The only reason I didn't give it a higher rating is the recipe is a little vague, as some people pointed out. I let the butter soften, but I found it did not mix in at all with the milk mixture, no matter how long I beat it with my mixer. Next time, I will melt the butter. Also, it didn't cook in the alloted time--I think this is because I'm at a high altitude (5000-plus feet). I went to the Bisquick Web site and they had the same recipe with slightly different/smaller measurements to fit in a 9-in. pie pan. (I used a deep square dish for this recipe, which worked fine and didn't overflow.) The site also said for high altitudes, adjust the heat to 375 degrees. Next time, I will probably just use the recipe on the Bisquick Web site. Just a note for high-altitude bakers--the Bisquick Web site actually connects to the Betty Crocker Web site, and it appears that all their recipes have high-altitude adjustment suggestions.

Wow, this was absolutely delicious! Easy, too. I accidently added a bit too much milk, so I added a bit more bisquick. The filling overflowed (used a cookie sheet like others suggested) but the pie baked up so nice. I also didn't have nuts for the top so I just made a brown sugar/butter/flour crumble and it turned out wonderfully. Almost like a warm pudding-apple-yumminess that I will definitely make again!

This was very tasty and everything turned out well. I only had 5 smallish apples on hand so I halved the recipe. I melted the butter for the part you pour over the apples, but left it cold for the topping, as a previous review had suggested. Also, I baked it at a highter temp (around 350), until it started to brown, then reduced the temp so it wouldn't burn. I will be making this again.

This came out pretty good but I did have a couple problems. This recipe doesn't say which amount of butter goes where and if you don't bake alot it's confusing. I think the submitter should have stated which amount of butter goes where..Also the strussel topping did NOT crumble and I have made crumble topping before. I tried to adjust it but it didn't work. Instead my boyfriend and I just spread it on top which was also pretty tasty. Other than these two problems it was pretty good.

I enjoyed the taste of this pie very much but it does take a little more work and not as quick to "whip up" as most 'impossible' pies.

I had some Jiffy brand baking mix I wanted to use up and a few very sad looking golden delicious apples. I only had enough for 5 cups of apples. I found the 'crust' batter to be very thin but proceeded, as I remember another reviewer commenting the same thing. After about 5 min. in the oven it started to ooze over the side of the 10 inch pie dish. To save my oven I just put a cookie sheet underneath to catch the drips. It took about an hour to bake at 325. The crumb topping is wonderful. I added 1.5 tsp. cinnamon and 1/2 tsp. nutmeg. The spices were perfect, the apples were done perfectly, and the taste is very nice. I am whipping up some cream for the top to serve to co workers. I just had to try a small sliver to make sure it was presentable. Very easy and quick recipe, also nice because it uses ingredients one has on hand. *I also melted the butter for the 'crust' batter, but kept the butter in small cubes for the crumb topping. thanks for this nice recipe. It's different, not your average pie, cobbler, or crisp.

This was very good! I was worried that I did it wrong, but it came out good! It it more like an apple cake that you make in a pie plate, but it was a hit here, nonetheless. I have an apple-peeler-corer-slicer from PC, so that made the process MUCH easier! THANKS FOR SHARING!