"These mints are so good! They're the soft, melt-in-your mouth kind that remind you of trips to your grandparents' house. Yum! This is best done on a marble slab, but can be done on a very clean baking sheet, although it may affect the temperature of the candy." — AMY CATES
Watch video tips and tricks
This is a great receipe. I have made these before but had lost the receipe. Since my receipe had been handed down over the years I wasn't able to replace it until now. Pulling the mints make all the difference. My mother and I used to make a double batch and hers were always better. She always got more pulls in than I did. This is a fun receipe to make with friends. The success isn't in the receipe but in the candy maker. If you fail the first time try again.
So glad I found this website and this recipe again. My mom, grandmother and I used to make it for several years as Christmas gifts for friends and coworkers. We'd make mints of different colors. We'd make flavor varities such as spearmint (our favorite) as well as raspberry, strawberry, vanilla etc. We'd have different colors for each flavor.
Warning: you will really need a candy thermometer to determine candy temperature. Be careful, mixture is HOT and I burned my hand once while trying to pour it. You also have to work VERY FAST with pulling the candy and cutting it before it sets up, because it starts setting up fast. It's best to have several family members present to help because it "moves fast." Great recipe for inexpensive gift giving. I think we'll try it again this year!
I tried this recipe 3 times and could not get it to turn out It was like eating a mint flavored sugar cube. I followed the recipe EXACTLY even using the marble slab. After the first time Irealized how fast it set up so try and try again . Iwould still like to have a recipe like this that works. I am very determined. It may have been just me though
I got it right my first time!!! I greased the pot before I put the sugar, butter and water in it to prevent crystals from sticking. I also covered the pot for the first 3 minutes or so to wash any crystals down the sides. I found that the recipe needs a little more peppermint flavoring - not strong enough for my taste! Also, while it tastes good, it's not quite the light and fluffy melt-in-your-mouth mint I was expecting. This might be because I only heated it to 265 - next time I'll go all the way to 280!
I learned to make these from my grandma. As another said, a candy thermometer is a must.
Also...DO NOT stir the misture in the pot. Just let it sit and boil.
One last trick that my grandmother swore by - make these on a sunny day. If you make them on an overly cloudy day, they won't turn out right. The humidity level effects the candy and they usually "turn to sugar" as she called it (the candy is very grainy and not the smooth, melt in your mouth texture that it should be).
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Grandmama Pampas' Old-Fashion Pull Mints
Serving Size: 1/48 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 48
Amount Per Serving
Calories from Fat: 9
Holiday cookies, cakes, pies, and breads. Get recipes and inspiration.
Get time-saving recipes to save your busy life.
Find just the right recipes for your holiday get-togethers.
These chocolatey, minty brownies will be a hit at St. Patrick’s Day.
See how to make your own old-fashioned kettle corn from scratch!
These dark chocolate coins are the currency of pure deliciousness.