I have not tried this recipe, but read the reviews. I have a suggestion. I make several types of thumbprint cookies during Christmas, & I always make my "thumb" print AFTER they cook. As soon as my cookie sheet leaves the oven, I set it on my hoosier cabinet, & use my All Clad 1tsp measurer to press the indention into the top of the cookie. I quickly work through all the cookies, making the dent, then start over to make sure it didn't "puff" back up again. Then, I let them cook, & insert the filling for my thumbprints later. I have NEVER had a problem getting a thumbprint cookie to set up using this method.
Was this review helpful?
2 users found this review helpful
I have not tried this recipe, but read the reviews. I have a suggestion. I make several...