Very good recipe, but I added nutmeg to taste, and it was perfect!

We made 6 full recipes of this - after Christmas - it was that good!

Oh my, this is great stuff. Loved the recipe, Thank you!!

This is a great eggnog recipe! Its soo fast and easy to make. Everyone liked it so well that we ended up making 4 batches of it. This is a keeper!

Can also substitute Vanilla Extract for Banana Extract. yummy!!!

I tried this version of eggnog because I wanted a recipe that didn't call for beating the egg whites separately. I thought it was too sweet until I "lightened it up" with some Southern Comfort. After that, it was excellent!

Yummy....this is great tasting eggnog! My whole family loved it, especially my teenage son.

Oh so good. Creamy and easy to make. Everyone loved it1

This recipe is so good! Adding a bit of pumpkin spice is needed, though. It isn't as rich nor as thick as commercial ones, but it has a good rich mouth 'feel' and the taste is certainly there. I think if anyone wanted a thicker 'store-bought' version, just use half and half instead of the milk and you are there. It looks beautiful in Christmas glasses with a dollop of whipped cream and a sprinkle of cinnamon, nutmeg and a candy cane stir stick makes even grandpa smile! It was a hit at our home and is going into the 'keeper' file! Thanks

Totally awesome recipe! I have young children, so I was afraid to use raw eggs, so I used Egg Beaters...turned out awesome! I can't imagine it being better with real eggs. Will definately be making this again!

This was lovely, though I prefer mine a little richer. Perhaps I added too much milk...

Awesome, perfect, delicious, and incredible!!! Every neighbor in my complex is drooling over this eggnog! Thanks a million for a simple, great eggnog!

Perfect!!! I just used a whole 1/2 pint of whipping cream, and I thought the texture was exactly what I thought it should be. I have never been able to have more than a sip of the store bought stuff, but I can not stop drinking this! We add a pinch of cinnamon and some cool whip to top it

This recipe was awesome! My son liked it but I loved it. I added 1/4 teaspoon of pumpkin pie spice, one teaspoon of nutmeg and top capfuls of imitation rum and gave it a good shake. Incredible! It also pays to shake it before serving. I loved it, because I know how to pronounce everything that went into making it. Even if it cost the same as store brand I will never buy it again!

I'm not supposed to consume dairy, so I relied on my children's reviews. "Ooh!" they squealed. "It's just like the kind we get at the store... except a gazillion times better!" Watching their pleasure in the eggnog, I finally cheated and had a tiny sip myself--and they were right. We will definitely be making this again this year and every year after.

This was so amazing! I live in a country that has never heard of eggnog, so this was a godsend for me! (Everyone who tried it for the first time loved it too!)