I am so angry that I made this recipe, and I blame allrecipe.com. Let me explain. I searched for "sugar cookie" on the website through my phone, and I sorted by rating. "Easy sugar cookies" comes up at the top of the list, while "chewy sugar cookies" comes up several pages later even though it is highly rated. So I made the "easy sugar cookies" by mistake, and they are nasty. You might as well eat a spoon full of flour. They are dry and lack flavor. The other recipe (chewy sugar cookies) uses twice as much vanilla, which I mix with a little lemon extract. It also uses two eggs that makes it chewy.
Easy doesn't always equal tasty. Don't waste your time with this cookie if you want a chewy bakeshop style cookie.
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
I am so angry that I made this recipe, and I blame allrecipe.com. Let me explain. I searched...