EAGLE BRAND® Frozen Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Reviews More Reviews

Most Helpful Positive Review

Mar 24, 2009

I used the recipe twice now, cooking for my beautiful wife to be whom loves peanut butter. The first time I followed the instructions to the 'T', except the pie crust. I trusted some other reviews as well as my taste bud 'instinct' and used pre made Oreo pie crust. The filling did not satisfy our hopes. It left me feeling a robbed and broken man... I just knew this pie had potential of magnificent proportions. So, after some time pondering, I came back to this with my sleeves rolled up and I wasn't leaving with another disappointment. My heart just couldn't take it. All I did for the second time around was switch the vanilla and lemon juice amounts, even adding just a little more vanilla because I kicked the peanut butter up to 1 cup. Again using that magical pre made Oreo Crust, AND IT BECAME ONE OF MY TOP FIVE FAVORITE DESERTS OF ALL TIME!!!! Adding a little more peanut butter made it a little more creamier!!!!!!! A day or two in the freezer and it still isn't losing it's phenomenally smooth texture! It probably wouldn't last past a few days though... EVERYONE IN THE HOUSE KILLS IT!

—David

See full review »

Most Helpful Critical Review

Jan 06, 2008

I don't reccomend the crust...I would go for a pre-baked ready pie crust for this. Mine got chewy and it was hard to even out in the pie pan. Also, I think there was an error in the recipe. I think the amounts of Vanilla and Lemon juice should be switched. Way too much lemon and not enough Vanilla to me. Not sure if I would try this one again with so many more different recipes out there.

—M.J.A.

See full review »

23 Ratings

Jul 06, 2010

This is a great recipe. Easy, fast and really good. I was a little worried about using Rice Krispies in a crust but they worked out fine. Followed the recipe with the exception of cutting the fresh lemon juice back to 1 tablespoon and thought it was perfect. I also didn't drizzle the fudge topping on until right before serving. Chopped mini reese's cups and sprinkled those and a few peanuts on top too. YUM! The first piece did not cooperate when I tried to remove it from the pan. I dipped the bottom of the pie in shallow hot water for a few seconds and that problem was fixed. Very pretty presentation and a great ending to our 4th of July meal.

—abapplez

See full review »

Feb 18, 2009

This was incredible. The smooth and silky peanut butter filling is a real treat. Plus with the fudge topping, you can make it look fancy. I made TWO changes that I should mention. I added just one TBSP of lemon juice because I felt two would be a bit too much lemon. Also, for the crust I used an off-brand honey nut cheerios because it was what I had. It all worked though and this is a definite keeper recipe!

—Jbooshey

See full review »

Nov 07, 2007

I made this recipe for my husband's birthday and it turned out great. I have made the other peanut butter pie recipe with confectioner's sugar and cool whip and this is much better IMO. I made a couple of modifications on this recipe. I did not make the crispy rice crust and used a prepared Oreo pie shell instead which worked perfectly with this recipe. I sprinkled Heath baking bits on top. I also reduced the whipped cream to approx. 3/4 cup to make a denser pie.

—KLISTER

See full review »

Feb 09, 2009

This is by far the best peanut butter pie I have ever had!!! I have had it every year for my birthday for the past 15 years or so. It can not be beat. I have tried other peanut butter pies in the past and they do not even come close to the creamy deliciousness of this pie. If you do not use this recipe, do not even bother to make peanut butter pie. The rice crispy crust is very good, but if you have leftovers it gets soggy so I would recommend you use a chocolate graham cracker crust or Oreo crust. It is just as good. The filling is so smooth and luscious. It is just a delicacy!

—Scullysioux

See full review »

Nov 19, 2007

Well im in 7th grade and i made this for my math class party and evryone loved it its great!!!!!!!

—carissa224

See full review »

May 24, 2010

this pie is a summer get together staple dessert- so incredibly delicious! the tang of the lemon juice with the peanut butter is to die for- although i do substitute fresh whipped cream for the cool whip (we dont like cool whip in my house). the result is an even richer and more decadent pie. i top off this masterpiece with a michigan favorite: Sanders Hot Fudge sauce. superb!

—stee322

See full review »

Rate This Recipe

Edit

Glad you liked it! Your friends will, too:

Did you tweak the recipe? Edit and save your own version of it!

Edit this recipe

More Recipes Like This See all

EAGLE BRAND(R) Peanut Butter Fudge

EAGLE BRAND(R) Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars

Easy Peanut Butter Cookies by EAGLE BRAND(R)

Peanut Butter Chocolate Pie

Chocolate Chiffon Pie by EAGLE BRAND(R)

Traditional Peanut Butter Pie

EAGLE BRAND(R) Quick Chocolate Mousse

Sweet Potato Pie from EAGLE BRAND(R)

Sweet Potato Pecan Pie by EAGLE BRAND(r)

Chocolate Peanut Butter Chip Cookies

Nutrition

Calories
789 kcal
39%

Carbohydrates
47.2 g
15%

Cholesterol
109 mg
36%

Fat
52.3 g
80%

Fiber
2.9 g
12%

Protein
12.3 g
25%

Sodium
408 mg
16%

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.

Nutritional Information

EAGLE BRAND(R) Frozen Peanut Butter Pie

Serving Size: 1/8 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 8
Amount Per Serving
Calories: 789
Calories from Fat: 471

% Daily Value *
Total Fat 52.3g 80 %
Saturated Fat 27.4g 137 %
Cholesterol 109mg 36 %
Sodium 408mg 16 %
** Potassium 150mg 4 %
Total Carbohydrates 47.2g 15 %
Dietary Fiber 2.9g 12 %
** Protein 12.3g 25 %
Sugars 32.6g
** Vitamin A 25 %
** Vitamin C 13 %
** Calcium 6 %
** Iron 44 %
** Thiamin 19 %
** Niacin 50 %
** Vitamin B6 13 %
** Magnesium 11 %
** Folate 34 %

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet. Your daily values may be higher or lower depending on your calorie needs.
** Nutrient information is not available for all ingredients. Amount is based on available nutrient data.
(-) Information is not currently available for this nutrient. If you are following a medically restrictive diet, please consult your doctor or registered dietitian before preparing this recipe for personal consumption.