My late sister-in-law introduced this salad to the family decades ago and it's become a treasured family tradition, and I'm asked often to bring this to company events. To those who noted that the cookies become mushy too quickly, here's the secret. ONLY USE KEEBLER FUDGE STRIPE COOKIES! They don't disintegrate and actually, the salad gets better after a few hours. While the Keebler cookies soften, they continue to hold their shape for a very long time. It's not unusual for us to continue eating this salad three or four days after it's made (I make huge quantities!). And, please...whatever you do, don't eliminate the buttermilk! That's what gives this salad such a unique taste!!
Was this review helpful?
2 users found this review helpful
My late sister-in-law introduced this salad to the family decades ago and it's become a...