Made these today, though modified it based on others reviews. I kept the cocoa powder. Can't tell if it is the vanilla or that which leaves a funny aftertaste. I used half crisco/half butter. Half dark and half light brown sugar. mini reeses cut in half and frozen. mini kisses (they had no chunks), peanut butter chips, inadvertently bought chunky Jiff, so I used that. Baked 7 minutes on parchment. Then realized I forgot baking soda. But they came out beautiful anyway. After tasting, I was surprised to see that the PB flavor was so mild, like others have said. I realized that there is no salt. Next time I will throw in a tsp of salt or more to bring out the PB flavor. I like my PB salty. Either way, these were a hit. But the first time my children didn't ask for a second cookie! VErY rich.
Was this review helpful?
2 users found this review helpful
Made these today, though modified it based on others reviews. I kept the cocoa powder. Can't...