I made these yesterday for the first time for my bowling team and they LOVED them! They actually taste like Reece's Pieces!
In order to save some time and money, I worked with ingredients that I already had, so I substituted the brownie mix for chocolate fudge cake mix and the funfetti frosting for regular vanilla frosting.
I tried to use a hand mixer to blend the frosting and peanut butter together better, but it got really dried out and thick, like cookie batter, so I had to add some almond milk (I'm allergic to regular milk) to bring it back to the right texture again. I definitely would NOT recommend doing that again!
Also, I would recommend using peanut butter that has a very smooth, creamy texture. I used a healthy one that had a lot of oil separation, so the frosting kind of fell apart when it got a little warm. It tasted amazing, but just looked a little weird.
Was this review helpful?
3 users found this review helpful
I made these yesterday for the first time for my bowling team and they LOVED them! They...