Recipe by mississippimarion
"I grew up eating king cake in NOLA but never really LIKING it. I finally decided to give it a go myself and have to say that this is, hands down, the best I've ever eaten. A conglom of several recipes, it's great with coffee, not too sweet, not too bready, with a rich, tender crumb and the traditional lemon/nutmeg flavors of a genuine NOLA king cake. Best eaten same day but pretty darn good the day after (if there are leftovers!). Enjoy, y'all!"
Watch video tips and tricks
1 (.25 ounce) package
rapid rise yeast
1 1/4 teaspoons
eggs at room temperature
Cream cheese filling:
1 (8 ounce) package
cream cheese at room temperature
lemon juice, or as needed
skipped cream cheese and went with almond filling. I didn't have buttermilk so I used almond milk with a teaspoon of vinegar..I would definitely go with buttermilk next time. I'm sure its a 5 star recipe. I think I just overbaked it a little.
I saw this recipe in my recent edition of All Recipes Magazine. My husband's family is originally from New Orleans so I thought I would bake this as a treat. I'm a very experienced baker so this seemed easy enough. I made the dough as directed however I didn't roll it out on parchment; it rolled easily on the counter and I just transferred it to the baking sheet as I would a traditional yeast coffeecake ring. It baked for the 45 minutes but I still thought it was a bit "doughy" even though the exterior was a nice medium golden brown. Also, the recipe advises to use a 8" round pan to mold the ring around. That didn't work for me because I was using a traditional 1/2 sheet pan so there wasn't room along the edges for the dough to fit so I used a bowl that was about 7". We did not like the filling. All you can taste is the tartness of the cream cheese. We prefer the traditional cinnamon version of King Cake. No one in my family was familiar with the lemon/nutmeg flavoring, however it really didn't taste like either but instead something rather bland and boring. This is the first time I've ever made a recipe that I gave a poor rating. I wanted to like it but it just didn't do it for me.
This king cake will sashay its way right into your Mardi Gras traditions. The dough is less eggy than some traditional king cakes and has the pleasant tang of buttermilk, and the cream cheese filling is the bomb. It's a king cake to convert the king-cake averse because it's both moist and not-too-sweet. I had to use 1 cup additional flour to get the dough to leave the sides of the bowl, but it rose beautifully. (My trick for proofing dough: A hot-water bath in a very low oven. Put the dough in a buttered medium ceramic bowl that you've warmed with hot water and dried, wrap it with plastic, and then nest it in a large ceramic bowl with a little hot water. Set the whole thing in your oven, and turn the oven to 110 degrees. In two hours, you'll have doubled dough.) I also added some vanilla bean paste and extra lemon juice to the icing to boost the flavor.
So glad y'all like it! I felt like this recipe should've come with a disclaimer: if you're looking for a cake that oozes cream cheese frosting, this isn't it. The "filling" nearly absorbs into the cake as it bakes, giving it a soft and flavorful but not runny center.
Also, nutmeg and lemon *were* the traditional NOLA King Cake flavorings (anyone remember McKenzie's? :); what we've had for decades now is a cinnamon substitution - basically, a cinnamon coffee cake with colored sugar. *meh*
Thanks for your comments, everyone! :)
We used this recipe for a recent volunteer event capped by a mardi gras celebration. I had previously cooked the king cakes for the event but passed the duty along this year. The baker made four of them. All our volunteers enjoyed the cake so much that we had to send a link to the recipe. Not too sweet, not too doughy, wonderful filling and icing. Traditional nutmeg rather than commercial heavy to cheaper cinnamon flavor. Very time consuming but from the eater's point of view...oh my, well worth the wait.
This is the first king cake recipe that I have made that doesn't use the traditional brioche dough. The buttermilk version used for this recipe results in a slightly more dense, thicker and sturdier dough, but it still has a nice sweetness to it. The cream cheese filling added just the right amount of creamy texture and sweetness...my husband now says that this is the best king cake he has ever had. The only modification I made was to add an extra 1/2 c. flour to the dough while it was mixing (as Allrecipes magazine suggested) - otherwise the dough would have been REALLY sticky. It is a very sticky dough to work with at first, but it is less messy after kneading/rising.
My husband misses Louisiana food and decided we should try this recipe. We added 1/2 cup more sugar to the filling and left out the lemon but otherwise followed the recipe. It was very good! It was rich and soft.
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Buttermilk King Cake with Cream Cheese Filling
Serving Size: 1/12 of a recipe
Servings Per Recipe: 12
Amount Per Serving
Calories from Fat: 131
We’ll help you get dinner on the table in no time flat.
Get recipes that work for your busiest days.
Delicious recipes, party ideas, and helpful cooking tips! Get a year of Allrecipes magazine for just $7.99!
Watch how to make this festive Mardi Gras cake.
Make the famous New Orleans cake with the surprise inside!
This carrot cake is dense and delicious, a real crowd-pleaser.