I thought this was really good! Very rich. I reduced the milk to 2 cups instead of 3, also I did not use fish added more scallops and shrimp. Next time will add a little more scallops. Served with brown rice and garlic bread. Will make again. Thanks for the great recipe.

This was excellent.I substituted clam juice for the water and half and half for the milk,as others had suggested. Thank your or sharing. Raster

We really enjoyed this recipe. I made hte following changes. I used only 3/4 C flour, no fish, more shrimp and scallops to make up for the fish, 2 C milk, 2 C cheese. It turned out like a nice casserole with this combination. Next time, I will use the same amount of cheese, but put in 3 C milk, as we would prefer it to have a more "alfredo" like texture. Also, next time we will bake the entree differently. I think it would be good to put pasta in a bowl, then pour the cheesy seafood mixture on top and then top with the crab mixture. The crab mixture tasted and looked like it would make a great golden topping for the cheesy seafood pasta.

This is a good base recipe but when I made it as is, I found it to be really bland. I added three more cups of cheese and just used 2 lbs of shrimp. I also added some white wine and chicken broth and green onions. I did as others suggested and cut the flour to 3/4 cup and added a little more hot sauce, I like things spicy. I topped the casserole with crushed up Ritz crackers and it turned out yummy!!

I am not typically a casserole kinda gal but this was a huge hit! It's rich and delicious. I gave it to my co-worker and the next day she told me her husband had a million thank you's for me! It's spreading like wild fire... It is labor-intensive and quite expensive with all that crab meat though. It's a special treat though and well worth all the cost and fuss.

I followed the recipe exactly as stated and it was perfect. You don't need lump crabmeat for this as the crabmeat forms a type of crust. I used "special" and it worked fine.

This recipe was delicious, if your a real seafood lover. I altered it a bit though. I cut the onion,pepper,butter,and seafood water to 1/2 a cup. 1 1/2 for milk, used 1 Tilapia fillet, about half pd. shrimp and scallops, and no crab meat. I kept everything else the same and add bread crumbs to the pepper, onion mix, and at the end with the parm cheese. So good,at the end with the breadcrumbs, don't be shy, the more the BETTER! Serve this with rice.It was about 5-6 servings. My hubby loved it!

I can see why this was rated so much and so well! It's easy and delicious! I cut the recipe down to 2 servings just to give it a try and I only had a can of crabmeat (yuk...not worth buying a can!!!) Anyway, it was terrific. Will make again with real crabmeat for company. It's hard to get good seafood in my area outside of Nashville, but got some really great baby bay scallops at Whole Foods and frozen flounder filets at Sam's. We bring home lots of Gulf shrimp when we go to Florida and so the seafood was pretty good. Can't wait to make it again!

My family loved this! I used cod in place of flounder, sea scallops and quartered them. I used 2 c. seafood broth in place of the water. I used 1/2 c. flour each time to cook in with the butter. I also used only 2 c. milk. I prepared ahead and let it set for 45 minutes before baking. We devoured it and only have ~1 c. left over. I made the Cheese Biscuits as JOOOCY79 recommended. Great dinner!

FABULOUS! I made this for dinner on New Years Eve and will make it again and again. REALLY GOOD!

Excellent! I served this to my parents and brother for Christmas and they absolutely loved it. It was full of seafood....I added a pound of lobster and used a pound of scallops instead of half....Delicious!!! I used about a quarter cup less flour for the mixture so it wouldn't get to pasty....worked good. It is the second time I make this recipe and everybody loved it....Will make it again in the near future...probably in the summer when the seafood it fresh.

This was just ok for me. It actually turned out very soupy, however when I heated up the leftovers the next day I noticed it was much thicker. I also used canned crab meat to cut back on cost.

Really is a versatile recipe. Used 2% milk as that is all I had on hand, but otherwise didn't change a thing. Very yummy, but also very rich! Couldn't eat a lot of it at a time, and ended up putting the rest in the fridge for leftovers.

I made this when the recipe was first posted and I loved it. Thanks Katy!

Very disappointing. No taste and very doughy. Ingredients too expensive to experiment with improvements.

Wow, I was very dissapointed. I had high hopes, however, it turned out really 'soupy' and just didn't have much too it. The taste was good, after I added lots of 'old bay' seasoning. I picked out and ate the shrimp but left the rest on my plate. Should be renamed "cheesy seafood dip". better luck to others. thanks