I just made this recipe yesterday, excited to try something "out of the box" if you will. I never stray too far from my array of awesome chocolate chip cookie recipes. So I made this for my father in law for his birthday. I am a professional baker, coming from a family of professionally trained chefs and my mother a professional baker. This recipe calls for Vanilla pudding mix. Interesting, personally I would've never made them, but hey this will be an experiment... How could you go wrong with so many good reviews I thought?? Well.. These are disgusting! You can ABSOLUTELY taste the fake vanilla flavoring from the pudding!!! I wasted my madagascar pure vanilla extract in this recipe! If you are a baker that loves butter, sugar, and pure vanilla extract flavor, these cookies are NOT for you. Do not waste your ingredients or time. POUND of butter to waste, all that top of the line flour. This recipe is a disgrace. I think it is for ...undeveloped taste buds and folks who think that gross fake vanilla pudding flavor is good? Good god. I will be throwing these away, every single one (and the huge bowl of cookie dough I won't be baking off). Sure, they look ok...don't be fooled. Negative stars!
Was this review helpful?
1 user found this review helpful
I just made this recipe yesterday, excited to try something "out of the box" if you will. I...