I tried this for Thanksgiving. It was pretty good but not great. Almost had too much going on. Will make again.

LOVE THIS PIE! It's nice to have something different from the traditional pie. I even made one after Thanksgiving because I hadn't had enough!

I don't really like Pumpkin Pie, but this was really good! I'm a novice at baking, and this was an easy recipe to make. It got rave reviews over Thanksgiving!

I made two of these, one for Thanksgiving dinner, one for the freezer. Everyone just love it. It's a nice little change from plain pumpkin pie.

Well, I made this one yesterday. We all love pumpkin and love apple butter, so I was anxious to try this one out. Basically, I'd say don't bother. It cooks up just fine, of course, but I was hoping for more apple-y flavor. All the apple butter added was the spices, which you could easily do with a normal pumpkin pie recipe. The ONLY thing worthwhile in this recipe was the crumble topping on the pie. Now, I use a topping like that on all my muffins, but never tried it on a pie. It is very good, and I'll do that part again. But for the base of the pie - nahhhhhhh. Too many ingredients for too little results! I was hoping for a more pronounced apple butter taste in there. So, if you hate your own pumpkin pie recipe, then try this one - otherwise, this will leave you with a partial can of pumpkin, an open can of evaporated milk, and a pie that you'll wonder why you bothered.... sorry!

This recipe was great, although I replaced the pecans with chopped golden delicious apples. As, I have family members allergic to cooked pecans. It also brought out the apple flavor making a great combo of pumkin and apple

I do a lot of baking & wanted to try something new. I was excited to find this recipe here. I made it for Thanksgiving and I was really disappointed with it. I followed the recipe to a "t" & it was nothing more than ok to me. It looked beautiful, but it tasted bland. The filling was blah and the topping wasn't very sweet. I won't be making this again...sorry.

This was the first pumpkin pie I've ever made. I used apple butter from a local festival and it was absolutely mouth watering!

Like so many others, I made this for Thanksgiving and it turned out wonderful! I used homemade "All Day Apple Butter" and the "Basic Flaky Pie Crust" from this site. Being a traditional pumpkin pie lover, I was pleased to taste so much of the pumpkin flavor in this pie, even though half of the pumpkin is replaced with apple butter. The end result was a spiced complex flavor that really complemented the dinner feast. I agree with another reviewer that, while nice, the streusel topping does not make or break this pie and should be considered optional. This recipe is definitely a keeper and I plan on making this for the other half of the family on Christmas!

very good a new twist on an old favorite, I added my home made apple butter to it and it turned out very good, thank you a keeper

This was one of the most disappointing pu mpkin pies I've ever eaten. It was bland and just not tasty. My mom said it was a good thing the turkey turned out so well!

Tasted great and was beautiful-I was afraid the apple butter would be too strong a taste but was perfect. Everyone loved the topping. Thanks!

Great pie. The only mistake I made was halving the crumb topping. I thought it was going to be too much but I will def use all next time. Delicious.

I am not a fan of pumpkin pie but this is great! My daughter loves "pumpkin pie" but said this pie is even better!

Mmm! Okay, I'm brand new to baking, cooking, etc. and this was the first thing I've ever made on my own and wow! it was awesome! Incredibly easy to make and fun as well. It was something my entire family enjoyed and definitely requested for Thanksgiving!

This was delicious, will definitely keep making this one.

We make this last year for Thanksgiving, it was just "ok"