Husband loves amish potato and macaroni salad because it is quite sweet. So far, out of all the amish style recipes we have tried, this is his favorite. In fact, it got a thumbs up from everyone at the table, which is unusual at our house. I did not alter the recipe measurements, but I did use mayo rather than salad dressing. I also put the chopped celery and peppers to the side so that they could add them at the table. I offered dill weed and smoked paprika at the table to top it off as well.
There was a lot of extra dressing but by tomorrow I am sure it will have been absorbed by the noodles. It was quite sweet but the dill pickle relish provided a nice contrast to the sweetness.
This will become one of our go to macaroni salad recipes. Thank you for a great recipe!
Was this review helpful?
0 users found this review helpful
Husband loves amish potato and macaroni salad because it is quite sweet. So far, out of all...