This recipe is great!My whole family loves them, and my brother says they are the best cookies he has ever had!

Way, way too sweet and doughy.

WHat can I say I needed something quick and yet unique and tasty to put on cookie platters for Valentines Day work party.........only problem..........keeping them on the platter till they left for work....everyone in the house wanted more more more........ A great recipe......rich sweet and decadent.......and shhhhhhhhh soooooooo easy. The only addition I made was that on accident I opened a package of chocolate and peanut butter chips and they were added .....end result just a new demention to the taste.......and it was great........ Thanks so much for this recipe it will be a new family and party favorite..........and easy for kids to help with too..........

Update 12/07: I just made these again and they were the best yet. I made according to the recipe except I used a DH German Chocolate mix and added about 1/2 cup of pecans. These were absolutely wonderful. Super fudgy and no one would guess how quick and easy these were to make. I used a cookie scoop and got 2 sheets of cookies. These took about 12 minutes to bake. Previous review of 12/05: These were very quick and easy. I used a Duncan Hines spice cake mix and French vanilla pudding. In addition to the chocolate chips, I added some pecans and a handful of white chocolate chips. I was skeptical about the recipe not calling for any eggs, but they were perfect in texture...they didn't spread too much and the next day are still crisp on the edges and chewy in the middle. Because of the extra ingredients I added, I had to press everything together so it would stay in a ball when placed on the cookie sheet, but it was worth it because the pecans are great with the spice flavor. I used a cookie scoop and baked them about 10 minutes.

Super easy recipe especially if you are participating in a cookie swap! I added another 1/3 cup of oatmeal. It did take my new oven at least 12-15 min. of baking time like another reviewer mentioned. I made my balls generous so I got maybe 20 cookies from this recipe.

I really liked these! Very chewy and tasty. Ahen I first made them I really noticed the butterscotch flavor, but after I kept them in the freezer and then thawed, it wasn't as noticeable. Still it's a great recipe that was so quick and easy to make and tastes great!

I didn't care for this cookie at all, and the recipe doesn't make much at all.

Versatile recipe and nice to make if low on flour and butter. Perfect for what I needed; have lots of mixes and puddings, and sour cream I needed to use up. I used a BUTTER PECAN mix, butterscotch pudding, and BUTTERSCOTCH CHIPS. I also had an egg yolk and some egg wash from a bread I had made, so measured 1/4 of the egg wash and threw in along with the egg yolk. I therefore added about 1/3 cup more oatmeal. Used a combo vanilla and butter flavor extract. These scooped out so easily on the cookie sheet using a cookie scoop and even with a medium scoop, they make alot. Did not spread much so can put alot on each sheet without fear of overcrowding. The taste is great and does not taste like cakemix at all. Tastes like there is a ton of carmel, or brown sugar and butter in them. Yum. Also threw in 1/3 cup of raisins and that was a nice addition. Very nice.

Great recipe, i substituted Devil's Food Cake mix and Vanilla pudding. Also, instead of 1 cup of choc chips i did one cup mixed of choc chips, white chips and walnuts. My Husband loved them.

I have made these many times and ALWAYS get great response! Delicious and EASY!

I make cookies for church every week, and this recipe has become my standby...the variations are endless. I've gotten super raves and requests for the recipe with these combinations, all with Duncan Hines mixes, plus I always add 1tsp of baking powder: 1. golden butter cake/French vanilla pudding/Crasins 2. lemon cake/lemon pudding/lemon zest/chopped pecans/dipped the balls in sugar before baking 3. golden butter cake/cookies & cream pudding/choc chips

These were AWESOME! Every single person that I shared them with absolutely LOVED them! They requested that I make them again soon!

I wasn't a big fan of the butterscotch taste but loved the concept. I think I will use chocolate cake and pudding mix next time for a brownie type cookie. Since my daughter liked this cookie I will make again with a few changes.

If you are used to baked goods that are entirely homemade, this isn't the recipe for you. The use of the cake and pudding mixes makes the cookies taste "artificial." However, if you need something quick and easy to make, these are fine. My husband and parents loved these, but they didn't taste good to me.

Oops! In my earlier comment about using this recipe to make great brownies, I forgot to mention to be sure to make the changes I stated earlier (ie, substitute 1/4 c. packed brown sugar for the pudding mix, and add 1 tsp. baking powder to the dry mixture) and use a Devil Food Cake Mix.

"Yuck" would be a generous rating. I was very disappointed with these cookies. Far too oily and "unique" taste was not as good as even the most basic Toll House recipe. I won't be making these again.

Unusual. I can't really say I liked them yet I couldn't stop eating them, and I normally have no problem throwing something away. So I'm not sure. Try it, it's different.

These are a staple for me...I always have to buy enough ingredients for two batches otherwise they disappear too quickly! I use at least a cup of oats per recipe, sometimes more, which probably helps to cut down the sweetness.

These were a hit with the kids. This is the first cookie recipe I've made that actually made more cookies than the recipe stated :) Not too sweet for me. I had to bake for 15 minutes. We'll make these again.

This was a quick easy recipe that everyone loved! We will be making this recipe again!