Allrecipes home
bookmark
 

Wine Advice: Why Miles Hates Merlot

By:   Carl Hanson

Merlot is much maligned. In the movie "Sideways," the insufferable wine snob, Miles, won't touch the stuff. It just doesn't get any respect. But why?

In a way, Merlot was a victim of its own success.

As Americans began to rediscover wine in the late 1980s, they often turned to silky, soft, smooth Merlot. Round and luscious, Merlot was a terrific alternative to hard, tannic Cabernet Sauvignon. It was just so easy to love!




Boom and Bust

The result of all this clamoring for an approachable red wine was the notorious California Merlot boom. Growers saw dollar signs and began to plant it everywhere--everywhere!--whether it wanted to be there or not. And very often, it did not. 

During the mid-to-late 1990s, grape growers planted acre after acre of cool weather-loving Merlot in the Central Valley, a long, furnace-like strip that runs from Sacramento to Southern California. Here, high temperatures and too-fertile soils led to enormous crops, which gave a diluted, unpleasant vegetative taste to the resulting wines.

Merlot's reputation may have been sullied by the overwhelming volume of low-quality grapes from the Central Valley whose weak, washed-out flavors overshadowed the high-quality Merlot still being produced in cool-weather spots of California, like Sonoma, Napa and Carneros, where cool Pacific mists mediate the temperatures.

For many Americans, however, the inexpensive, ubiquitous and bland Central Valley Merlots became their only reference point. But quality California Merlots remain, as always, warm and ripe and inviting; nothing to shy away from at all, despite what Miles says.

 
ADVERTISEMENT
 
Select Your Version:  United States  |  Canada  |  United Kingdom & Ireland  |  Australia & New Zealand  |  Frequently Asked Questions What's this?