Add a Comment

Making Eggs Benedict

By:   Allrecipes Staff

A constant at celebratory breakfasts and brunches, eggs Benedict is often considered a difficult and extravagant dish.

Broken down into basic components--toast, ham, eggs, and hollandaise--there is nothing to fear in preparing eggs Benedict, except maybe the calories.




Dazed by Hollandaise?

Two things define eggs Benedict: poached eggs and hollandaise sauce. And those two items are the reason this dish seems so daunting. Without them, though, it's not quite Eggs Benedict. Learn these two steps, and any sort of Benedict is possible.

  • Begin by poaching the eggs. Crack the egg first into a separate container, and then boil water with a tablespoon or two of vinegar added. Now stir the water in a wide circle and add the whole egg. The slightly acidulated water will set the eggs quickly, while the whirlpool of water will keep the egg in a ball. Poach at a simmer for four to five minutes for set whites and soft yolks.

  • Hollandaise sauce is an emulsion of eggs and butter, which seems tricky to create. The eggs and butter must blend at just the right temperature--warm enough to melt the butter, but cold enough to keep from scrambling the eggs--then stay at that temperature until served. The secret? A double-boiler and a thermos. Carefully read the recipe, use a bowl set over simmering (not boiling) water, and stir, stir, stir. Hollandaise, it should be noted, does not like to be rushed. Take the time to make sure each step is done before moving on. The double-boiler ensures the eggs won't scramble as they heat, and the thermos ensures the sauce is held at an optimum temperature until served.


Dress It Up

Now is the time to get creative. Use favorite breads, meats, or veggies to make up a new personal favorite.

  • English muffins are the standard bread at the base of eggs Benedict. Their chewy texture contrasts nicely with the eggs, and helps absorb the sauce. But don't get stuck on English muffins. Plain toast is often cited as the original bread for eggs Benedict, and any toasted bread, from focaccia to challah, is excellent.
  • A slice of Canadian bacon often comes next. But again, substitutions are more than welcome. Ham, bacon, pancetta, and prosciutto can all be used. Sometimes seafood is added--smoked salmon, crab cakes, or scallops. For a vegetarian option, spinach is common, making it eggs Florentine, or asparagus, lightly fried firm tofu, avocado, or just melted cheese.

Comments
connie melchiorre 
Jul. 10, 2009 6:40 am
Can you make Hollandaise Sauce ahead of time, by that I mean can I store it in the fridge? Please help me. Thank you Connie
 
Jul. 23, 2009 10:26 am
Hi Connie. You can't make it that far ahead of time - but you can make Hollandaise an hour or two before serving. Just use a clean, hot thermos (one you DON'T use for coffee); pour the fresh Hollandaise sauce into the thermos. This is what restaurants do to keep the sauce hot for service.
 
Sep. 10, 2009 11:08 am
Connie - I use this recipie for Hollandaise sauce. It's super easy & really quick. No need for a double boiler or thermos! http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Blender-Hollandaise-Sauce/Detail.aspx
 
HERBY 
Dec. 29, 2009 1:47 pm
Being a person,who does not care for scrambled eggs!!! many years ago i was in Vegas and went to one of there famous buffets,think it was at Ceasers?? they had a scrambled egg,that i went back for 3 times(fabulous)thay tasted like they had whip cream in them ???have never seen anything close to them since. hoping someone knows???
 
Pam Connolly 
Dec. 30, 2009 5:41 pm
I make these a few times a year for at least 8 and have discovered several short cuts. The muffins can be split, brushed with butter and put under the broiler to toast; the sauce can be held at room temp. for a short time while doing the rest of the prep, and then put under the broiler when the dish is assembled; and if you have an electric skillet with sides - they work great for poaching a dozen eggs at a time. Yum!
 
kuuipo 
Jan. 7, 2010 3:43 pm
What about using Hollandaise sauce from the store, or Hollandaise sauce mix? How good are they, and hich one is the best tasting?
 
technogeek67 
Jan. 9, 2010 2:52 am
Herby; I used to serve this in my establishment, and yes, there is whipped cream in it. Whip the eggs separately, then whip the cream and fold the two together. one final pass through the food processor, and treat it as though they are just scrambled eggs. Cook over med high heat until they reach the dry mucus stage, then (my option) drizzle with hollandaise. (I gave this recipe to Caesar's, but they omit the sauce)
 
Jan. 22, 2010 6:59 am
Kuuipo - If you ever make Hollandaise from scratch, whether the double-boiler method or blender method, you will never use the stuff in the pouch again. Really no comparison.
 
WE2R1 
Jan. 24, 2010 5:13 am
My mother raised us on eggs benedict. Now it has been going for three generations. We always use english muffins, deviled ham and cheese sauce made from scratch, and top with paprika. The flavors with the eggs all compliment wonderfully. The cheese sauce is a great alternative to the Hollandaise. ENJOY!!
 
holly mac 
Jan. 26, 2010 8:44 pm
lots of tips and versions thanks all
 
Paul-ene 
Jan. 27, 2010 1:45 am
I love Eggs Benedict...one of my favorites to order for brunch. I shy'd from making it at home cuz it was time consuming. If your a busy mom or persons....here is a sure easy tip.....I shorten the time making with a Egg cooker(set the timer and let the machine poach the egg for you)I got my egg cooker from Williams-Sonoma. Works great!!! Perfect poach eggs all the time. I also don't fuss making homemade Hollandaise sauce. Don't listen to everyone that says store bought isn't any good. I have had many many eggs benedict and I use the KNORR dry packet Hollandaise sauce....just as tasty and so much easier than trying to make it from scratch. Plus, it reheats and saves in the fridge. I usually toast up my english muffin's in my big electric Dutch oven and fry my Canadian bacon in that pan as well. I sometimes add green onions, red onions or Sauteed Asparagus to the tops of my Eggs benedict too for a twist on flavors.
 
 
Something worth saving?

Register now to save all your favorites in your recipe box.

ADVERTISEMENT
 
Select Your Version:  Australia & New Zealand  |  Brazil  |  Canada  |  China  |  France  |  Germany  |  Japan  |  Mexico  |  Netherlands  |  Quebec  |  Russia  |  SE Asia

United Kingdom & Ireland  |  United States  |  Frequently Asked Questions What's this?