Great cookie! As others have said, if you're expecting a full pumpkin flavor, this isn't the cookie for you. The does seem to be a tad too much chocolate chip in it but it ends up being ok if you also add walnuts. If you're not putting in walnuts, i would say put slightly less choc chip. I also added a bit more pumpkin for pumpkin flavor. I did use 1/2 c white sugar and 1/2 c brown sugar and added 4 drops of red and 1 yellow for pumpkin color. MAKE SURE TO USE PARCHMENT PAPER!! The first time I made it, the cookies started to smoke (YIKES) and burn before it was fully cooked on the inside. The chocolate chips on the bottom of the cookie melted, spread, and burned the bottom of the cookie, even though I greased the cookie sheet and it sat in the middle rack. Brought it to work and everyone seemed to enjoy it. Someone said it was a "holiday explosion in your mouth" =)
Was this review helpful?
[
YES
]
2 users found this review helpful
Great cookie! As others have said, if you're expecting a full pumpkin flavor, this isn't the...