Conquering My Fear of Yeast Breads 
 
Oct. 12, 2009 10:50 am 
Updated: Nov. 9, 2009 10:38 am
Yeast breads.  A difficult subject for me.  I love baking and have perfected many cookie, cake, muffin and bar recipes.  But I’ve always avoided yeast breads.  They scare me.  So do fruit pies, but that’s a subject I’d rather not talk about right now.  Let’s tackle one fear at a time, shall we?

My fear of yeast breads began as a child.  My mom liked to make yeast breads from scratch, but she struggled with them.  I’m sure she was triumphant many times.  I can remember the many awesome Christmas mornings celebrated with her wonderful caramel pecan rolls.  Oh yum.  However, for some reason, I remember how she had trouble with the dough not rising, or it being too sticky, or deflating while baking.  Those things are what stuck out in my mind and have prevented me from trying it all these years

I have no problem using the bread machine though.  I’ve had many successes in that department, including making my own pizza crust, Jo’s Rosemary Bread, and Steakhouse Wheat Bread.  It still involves getting the right water temperature, measuring the ingredients correctly.  So what’s the big deal?  It’s the pessimist in me, the fear of failing.  It’s in my character to have anxieties and fears, but I have been conquering them one by one.  Another factor is the time involved.  I thought it would take all afternoon and a lot of patience that I don’t have. 

So this weekend I decided to try it.  French Bread Rolls to Die For was at the top of my list and seemed simple enough.  Also, I was planning on making beef stew – perfect to serve with!  As soon as I started, my worries dissipated.  Everything worked the way it was supposed to.  As for the time and patience required, it wasn’t a problem.  While the bread was rising, I went through our junk mail and clipped coupons.  The kneading and the waiting - it was actually very therapeutic.  Beginner’s luck?  I don’t know, but I want to try again!

Now there’s no stopping me!  I can’t wait to try these recipes:

Do you have any suggestions for me to try next?  Or do you have any cooking fears?  If so, what are they?
See you later dough, and you'd better rise!
X
Photo Detail
Wow! It actually rose!
X
Photo Detail
They rose again! I'm on a "roll!"
X
Photo Detail
 
X
Photo Detail
 
Comments
Oct. 12, 2009 11:10 am
Great blog and gorgeous pictures! I'm glad you conquered your fear:@) The rolls look delicious.
 
Oct. 12, 2009 11:24 am
Great story. Glad it worked out for ya !!! My fear is making bread bowls, been thinking about it for a long time and still haven't got brave enough th try :(
 
Oct. 12, 2009 11:36 am
We are very similar......I also have a fear of fruit pies and bread while I have mastered cakes, cookies, bars, and even candy. I decided this morning before I saw your blog that I want to conquer my fear of making bread. I always see other's beautiful photos and decided this is something I have to try again. I made rolls once time that never rose and turned out to be very dense cooked dough balls. When I make pizz dough, it is always too thick and doughy. I have my eye on "french baguettes" from this site. As soon as I make a trip to the commissary and buy a bag of bread flour, I will be trying this for myself. I have faith that it will work this time. Your rolls look amazing, Dianne!
 
Oct. 12, 2009 3:48 pm
Fun to read! Enjoyed your blogging and pictures. You will have so much fun with yeast breads! I think of making a yeast bread kinda like nurturing a special pet. It's a relationship. Here is my fear: cooking beef. I am just so worried that it won't be tender and edible! I have a real horror of tough, hard-to-chew slabs of meat, so when I do cook beef, it's ground beef! Maybe someday I will get over this and be able to cook & enjoy a prime rib!
 
Oct. 12, 2009 5:08 pm
Great job, Dianne! I make my own whole wheat bread every week, but I just make in my bread machine because is easier. I did make before French Baguettes and Clone of Cinnabon from this site, they both turned out excellent and were my first experiences.
 
Oct. 12, 2009 6:21 pm
I remember making my first loaf of bread when I was 21-I was so thrilled! I did take a picture-like a still life-I was so proud. When married to my second husband I made bread every week. Also raised chickens,rabbits, & did lots of cooking. The DH I have now wanted me to keep working & support my horses myself so I do. I miss being the "queen" of my house, but hope someday to retire & be able to do things more as I want, than always jumping to someone else's schedule.Keep the dreams alive!
 
rae Supporting Member (Click to learn more about Supporting Membership)
Oct. 12, 2009 6:22 pm
Great job! Yeast breads are really easy once you get over the fears. It took me years of trying and failing with them but I've got it down now. My fear is pie crust. Its very scary :(
 
Oct. 12, 2009 8:27 pm
Isn't it funny how such an old cooking tradition (I mean humans have been making bread almost forever) reduces us to weak-kneed fear. I finally, after too many years to mention, conquered my yeast phobia and have been baking all my bread ever since and now I only regret I waited so long. Now what I doubt I'll ever take on is fondant!
 
Oct. 12, 2009 10:25 pm
Great job Dianne. I have a bread machine that I utilize for it's dough making capabilities. More often than not, I will stop it at that point and bake away. I have done it the "old school" way and I much prefer it however time is usually the issue...maybe a little fear....but my biggest fear lies with fondant. That terrifies me.
 
Oct. 13, 2009 7:28 am
I love baking breads by hand, but I'm on the chubby side so I can't do it too often. My biggest fear is anything that involves a double boiler, like flan or mousse - I tend to make those from mix.
 
Oct. 13, 2009 5:38 pm
It is interesting reading about everyone's experience with this and also cooking fears others have. I like CookieWeasel's take on this: it is like nuturing a special pet.
 
pc Supporting Member (Click to learn more about Supporting Membership)
Oct. 15, 2009 1:13 pm
great job! i, too, will cook and bake almost anything (the mad scientist comes out when adjusting baking recipes!) sigh, my few attempts at yeast have been a failure. perhaps will borrow sis-in-law's bread machine. good luck, let me know how the cinnamon rolls turn out: the purchased ones are always welcome here (second only to Kringle from Wisconsin)
 
Oct. 17, 2009 8:54 pm
hi,when making dough of any kind just keep in mind the water you use must be at body temp, keep dough away from drafts,and your fears will soon go away and you will have more fun. when i am making bread this always comes to my mind bread is on of the few things our lord blessed when he was on this earth. may your dough always rise and enjoy
 
MelMel 
Oct. 25, 2009 3:57 pm
Hello Dianne! I am so glad I found your blog! I, too, am an Iowan now living in the Twin Cities, in a stressful job (bank examiner), with some health issues, who finds relief through cooking and baking. I have struggled with yeast breads also. They just intimidate me and, unlike you, I have not found the guts to give them a try yet. I can, however, help you with the fruit pies bit. My junior year of high school I won the prize for my Apple Pie at the Iowa State Fair. Pies are not nearly as intimidating as yeast breads! There are a few tricks of the trade though. The best pies crusts are made with lard. I know that sounds gross and it has become very hard to find, but it is the KEY to a dream crust. That being said, I personally still use shortening. I also pre-bake my crusts before I put in the filling. This assures the crust is crisp, not soggy. Make sure to remember to use a fork and poke some holes in the bottom of the crust to ensure that air gets in there too. There are a few tools on the market that make pie making a cinch! I have found all at my local bed, bath, and beyond. 1) Thin Aluminum pan. The heavy non-stick pans do not hold the crust in well. Stick to the old fashioned kinds that are like $3. 2) Aluminum ring to put over the edge of the crust to ensure the top of the crust does not get too brown. Use this for pre-baking as well as after you have put the filling in; removing just in the last minutes of baking. 3) Plastic zippered pie crust bag (?). This wonderful invention allows you to just put in one of your crusts [top or bottom], zip up, rolled out with a rolling pin, unzip, place pan upside down over crust, and flip. No mess and it lets you to use less water allowing for a flakier crust! Great invention! 4) Last, for any apple pies, one must get an apple peeler/corer. They make life so much simpler. Half of my time was always spent peeling apples. Not with this baby! It's wonderful. Well, I have used up a lot of my allowed characters and just generally gone on way too long, but I hope some of my comments help you to overcome the fear of fruit pies. Would love to see those as the next fear tackled. Good luck Dianne!
 
Oct. 26, 2009 7:34 am
Wow, thanks for all the tips MelMel! I would like to make an apple pie for Thanksgiving this year, so I will definitely use your tips! The problems I always have are the crust being soggy and the filling too runny. Any tips on the runny part? Thanks MelMel, it's nice to hear from a kindred spirit!
 
Nov. 9, 2009 10:38 am
Congrats on conquering your fear of yeast breads! I too had that fear and I think I just learned you have to follow instructions to a tee. If it says knead for 8 minutes, you have to knead for 8 minutes. And because my house is either cold or hot, I warm my oven while making the dough, then turn it off and let the dough rise in the warm oven. You'll love the clone of Cinnabon rolls and may I suggest the Fabulous French Loaves. That's the recipe I used to conquer my fear of yeast breads. Happy baking Dianne!
 
 
 
Something worth saving?

Register now to save all your favorites in your recipe box.

My Profile
Dianne
 Supporting Member (Click to learn more about Supporting Membership)
Home Town: Iowa City, Iowa, USA
Living In: St. Cloud, Minnesota, USA
Member Since: Jan. 2004
Cooking Level: Expert
Cooking Interests: Baking, Slow Cooking, Asian, Italian, Mediterranean, Healthy, Dessert, Quick & Easy, Gourmet
Hobbies: Walking, Photography, Reading Books, Music, Wine Tasting
 
ADVERTISEMENT
About Me 
Cooking is my passion! I'm trained as a civil engineer, but right now I'm working part-time in the natural foods section of a grocery store. I really like it, I get to be around food and it gives me more time to spend in my favorite place - the kitchen! I've been cooking since I was about 10 years old and my mom was in the hospital, I had to take over a lot of the kitchen duties. I'm married to a wonderful guy and have two black pugs. When I'm not cooking or working, I'm reading, taking pretty pictures, making jewelry, or exercising.
My favorite things to cook
My favorite things to cook are also my favorite to eat - desserts! I love baking cakes, muffins, cookies and bars. On the flip side, I am a cancer survivor and my husband has MS, so good nutrition is very important to us. I cook a lot of salmon, veggies and whole grains. I also love to cook food that is more gourmet, things that go well with a nice bottle of wine.
My favorite family cooking traditions
Both of my parents are excellent chefs and we have a lot of traditional family recipes that I make throughout the year and holidays. For the past 5 years Sunday nights are when I make new or "fancier" meals for my husband and I to enjoy before starting a new week. We pop open a bottle of wine and enjoy each other's company and a great meal.
My cooking triumphs
My raspberry chocolate truffle cheesecake. I made it for my sister's wedding shower and it was the hit of the party. Turtle Dove Cake is my husband's favorite, so rich it's to die for! I make it every year for his birthday.
My cooking tragedies
In college I tried to make carrot cake with cream cheese frosting. The cake turned out fine, but I tried making the frosting with low fat butter and cream cheese. It was a soupy mess! I learned that you have to use the real stuff when baking!
 
Select Your Version:  United States  |  Canada  |  United Kingdom & Ireland  |  Australia & New Zealand  |  Germany  |  France  |  China  |  Japan  |  Quebec  |  SE Asia  |  Netherlands

Frequently Asked Questions What's this?