I'm being generous by giving this three stars only because the end result tasted good despite it being a COMPLETE DISASTER as far as presentation. I've made many, many different pinwheel-style cookies in the past and have not had problems, but this one... well, it just didn't stay together. I followed the suggestions of other reviewers, refrigerating the dough prior to rolling it out and putting the jam mixture on, and I refrigerated overnight prior to slicing and baking. The dough was crumbly and broke apart easily; worse, the raspberry filling wasn't "sticky" enough to hold the cookie together and as it baked, the cookie spread to become a fragile mess... I bake cookies during the holidays to give out as presents, and this one cannot be given out because it looks TERRIBLE. Although they ended up tasting yummy (and I'm enjoying the mess for myself) it was far too much effort for a cookie that ends up not working out. There are plenty of other pinwheel cookie recipes out there... stick with those and skip this one.
Was this review helpful?
[
YES
]
3 users found this review helpful