This dish was fantastic - a huge hit at our party, we had 15 people so it's a good dessert to make for a crowd. I did have some problems - my pudding didn't set (waited 20 mins) and only set when it was put together and left in the fridge for a few hours....not a big deal except I didn't get the distict layers of brownie, whip cream and pudding - the pudding sunk into the brownie. Also I decided to use real whip cream to cut the sweetness and only added a little of real vanilla while whipping. For a crowd of 15 I doubled the recipe - such a GREAT dessert!! UPDATE - The second time I made it I used even more brownie and let the pudding set longer before assembling the dish....so yummy!!!

Reviewed On: Jun. 9, 2008

Update! I didn't want to give up on this recipes because the reviews were so good, so I kept at it. Finally it turned out, I stopped using the lattice crust and that helped - for some reason the apples were drying out but not cooking. I didn't add as much water as the recipe called for and I added lots of apple pie spice. This recipe really is a keeper, if it doesn't work the first time keep trying!

Reviewed On: Nov. 8, 2007

I am like Monica on Friends, looking for that perfect chocolate chip cookie recipe...well this is it! I have tried at least a dozen others and these ones are, by far, my favorite. I only make half of the recipe and always add salt. Maybe it's my oven, but my cookies are not cakey and always end up on the flatter side, but they are perfect and my husband LOVES them!

Reviewed On: Oct. 13, 2007