this recipe has been passed down in my family for many many generations and it is delicious however this recipe calls for water to make the gravy in the crockpot, you dont neede the water. the only thing the water serves to do is make it runny. put the roast in the crockpot, pour the cream of muchroom soup over nad sprinkle the onion soup mix on top of that, trust me it turns out beautifully, never in my history of cooking has this gone wrong. the juices from the roast make the gravy, omit the water.

Reviewed On: Apr. 5, 2009

I thought this was very good. but to the others out there criticizing recipes on this site, cant criticize accurately if you change the original recipe. makes no sense to say its bad or wasnt very good, if you dont first try it the way its supposed to be, because it might have been your changes that made it worse.

Reviewed On: Feb. 9, 2009

I did not care for this recipe.

Reviewed On: Jun. 3, 2008