Thought I would try something new with the butternut. Well I have just looked back to see what everyone else thought and was really surprised. We had it last night..following recipe exactly except decreasing the sugar amount a bit. Being from the south, I thought we would enjoy it...but NO way will I waste my other stuff again to make it. Truely sorry....

Reviewed On: Aug. 22, 2009

I love this cookie. Have been making them since I was a kid. In fact we used to call it Mack's (my brother) cookie because he was always asking for them. Some things other than coconut that you can add are raisins or extra chopped nuts. At Christmas I make these and before they get set I will put half candied cherry on them to give them a little extra pizazz. Oh...and I am in my 50's. :)

Reviewed On: May 29, 2009

My husband thought it was ok, I thought it tasted like pintos with lots of sugar in it. I did add the nuts and a tad of vanilla, but it just wasn't what I wanted out of a pie. Even tho it was easy, I will keep looking.

Reviewed On: Apr. 6, 2009