I sorted the reviews by most helpful and made them according the review that was second from the top. I made them w/o vanilla as I was out and used the creamy PB (the extra 1/2c as other reviewers suggested). This is my first time making them with PB and loved the salty/sweetness of this recipe. Thanks for the great addition to my cookbook!

Reviewed On: Feb. 26, 2009

I say this punch is ok. I've definitley had worse. I think next time I'll use less fruit punch and more lemon lime soda. I had hoped this punch would have more fizz.

Reviewed On: Aug. 24, 2008

I was quite disappointed after reading the reviews for this recipe. I even sorted them by most helpful and used 4 eggs and 3 cups of cheese. This was an ok recipe. I made it for a church function and it was bland. It needs a bit more tweaking before it gets 4 or 5 stars from me.

Reviewed On: Jan. 20, 2008